Sun 4 Dec 2011 | 09:41
Alesana Tuilagi and Tom Wood red carded following touchline brawl

73
Comments

Two players were red carded in the first half of a fiery Aviva Premiership clash between rivals Leicester Tigers and Northampton Saints yesterday. The Tigers won the match 30-25 in a game that had many talking points.

As you can see in the video below, powerful wing Alesana Tuilagi bumped off Chris Ashton before the England winger tracked back, caught him, and dragged him by his hair, sparking a touchline brawl that resulted in both Tuilagi and Tom Wood being sent off.

"You have to be a little bit careful, Ashton dropped a shoulder into Geordan Murphy after a kick and the tackle on Alesana, he's dragged him by his hair into touch," said Leicester's Richard Cockerill.

"I don't think there was a lot going on involving Alesana at all and he got the red card, we'll have to take a look and review it. He could miss Europe next week, which is massive for us on a massive call from the referee - Alesana hasn't thrown a punch, so what's he been sent off for?

"It's disappointing because I think the game was spoilt from that point. I've not seen all the angles but a yellow card for whoever they wanted to blame is enough there," he added.

Referee Wayne Barnes looked determined to get a stamp on the game, particularly after the way he handled last year's fixture. On that occasion it was Ashton and Manu Tuilagi who came to blows, and this time Barnes made sure the colour of the cards was red, despite having a few options.

"The sendings-off I thought were much to do with the rivalry, the lads were up for it - I thought yellow cards and settle it down would probably have been a better decision there," said Saints coach Jim Mallinder, who wasn't pleased with the officials for the call at after the winning try either.

Below are the match highlights, which feature the incident at the beginning of the clip

73 Comments

  • filth
    7:55 AM 21/12/2011



    C'mon Guys, Bring Back the Biff. You must admit, it's good to see a bit of fisty cuff now and again?

  • pretzel
    8:46 AM 07/12/2011

    Right and I suppose there should be a lack of forgiveness to the French for their football world cup something or other years ago from the Irish.... In australia...

    You do realise then perhaps you should have said Ashton needed forgiveness from the Samoans.... Then again, why? It's rugby, and I thought we all generally follow the "what happens on the pitch stays on the pitch" rule....

    I only argue that one point because the rest is semi valid, Ashton did grab tuilagi's hair and I don't believe the reaction should be "get a hair cut" I think the reaction should be sorting out the incident.

    Ashton can't control himself... Yes, I'd somewhat agree with that, we saw in the 6N that ROG got under his skin.

  • cheyanqui
    3:42 AM 07/12/2011

    Pretzel, I agree that "good conduct" sounds a bit silly...

    Until of course Eliota Fuimano-Sapolu shows up to a hearing

  • pretzel
    12:44 AM 07/12/2011

    Because why would Ashton ever need NZ or Aus forgiveness... let alone YOURS?

    Welcome to the real world where players do react to things and are a little grubby.

    No player is untouchable so why would the Tuilagi's be untouchable....

    Lets not forget where they originate from...Australia?? I don't think so...

  • mise
    9:22 PM 06/12/2011

    From the rfu link above:
    "Ashton, 24, was found guilty of pulling Alesana Tuilagi by his hair and dragging him from the field of play .....The Saints wing, who denied the offence...."
    denied the offence? He was accused of x and he _denied_ doing it?!?
    That's a bit silly, and probably added to his ban. (read rest of info at link before u start going on about the rules btw...)

  • sithepie
    9:16 PM 06/12/2011

    Ashton has since been given a 4 week ban by the RFU. I think this is fitting.

  • cheyanqui
    9:14 PM 06/12/2011

    http://www.rfu.com/News/2011/December/News%20Articles/061211_Disciplinary_Ashton.aspx

    Ashton gets a four week ban.

    Tuilagi and Wood get time served (67 minutes in the game).

    Geordan Murphy, Agulla, and Lawes get the administrative equivalent of a Yellow Card.

    Seems pretty fair all around. Perhaps Murphy deserved a bit more.

  • pretzel
    7:03 PM 06/12/2011

    I don't think you quite understand the real world actually....

  • pretzel
    7:02 PM 06/12/2011

    I disagree (once again) I made my decision regarding the knee when I first saw the incident, (well second saw it) I watched it over and over trying to stop it, and I am sure that Ashtons knee (or leg after watching again right now) is the first thing to make contact with Tuilagi... I'm not saying its worth the retaliation that came afterwards, but I know damn right if someone shoved me like that I wouldn't ignore it....

    But in all honesty, I'd have stopped it all at the yellow (at the most) and wouldn't have worried about citings etc. It is all getting a little too political and "off the pitch" now...

    I say get on with the game!

  • matthew
    1:56 PM 06/12/2011

    I don't buy the knee. It's not conclusive from the video (yes, Ashton's knee bends NEAR to Tuilagi's back, and it may have made contact, but only in the action of giving a shove, as opposed to being a kneeing), and it's strange how it wasn't mentioned - especially by Cockerill, who anyone would expect to be quite vocal about such a thing - until the disciplinary hearing. It smacks to me of someone with nous looking at the video and working to minimise Tuilagi's ban.

  • pretzel
    8:50 AM 06/12/2011

    What a very odd comment, what ties does Aus/NZ have with Manu? Therefore why would anyone need forgiving for the Manu incident? I mean if they can go on a tour together in the world cup I'm pretty sure they have gotten over it.... So why should YOU hold a grudge??

  • pretzel
    8:46 AM 06/12/2011

    I disagree, if you watch the may incident he shoves manu's head, whilst putting a knee in manu's back, id say that yellow was deserved...

  • pretzel
    8:38 AM 06/12/2011

    It doesn't matter That it was uploaded 3 months ago, it was an old incident. If you hear something about a game on Saturday then you search for it online if it's not in RD. if it IS on RD then the buck stops there an I don't spend time "googling". So my point is "how were we supposed to know it was on YouTube?" You comment a if we all frequently watch BOD incidents and know them clearly, when I honestly think the firs time I've seen that is when you posted it, AND I am saying both incidents are not highlights in either players career, so where do you keeping getting the idea that we all want to bum lick BOD for his effort yet hang Ashton for his?!?!?!

    Fact still remains that if RD uploaded that video tomorrow you'd have a million "hate BOD" comments going up anyway, so what are you trying to achieve? Anyone who has been on RD for long enough is well aware of the vendetta against BOD that many users have...I personally think the guy is a great player, however this incident is a shame, much like Tana is brilliant and his indiscretion regarding BOD was a shame, but life goes on...

  • pulsey
    2:47 AM 06/12/2011

    Agreed.

    Long hair is never useful in sport.

  • anonymousno7
    2:30 AM 06/12/2011

    I completely agree with you, punch ups should be left to be discussed in the boxing forums.

  • rich_w
    11:01 PM 05/12/2011

    The only part of all your comments I really disagree with is the 'purposefully going for the hair'. I read all of your comment, and disagree with your logic. Sure he tackles high, no doubt about that. He probably could have chopped his legs, true. But you quite often see tacklers going for the chest/shoulders when tracking back. I put this down to attempting to stop the offload, could also be that when tackling a running man from behind around the legs you are liable to cop a boot in the face.

    Either way, he tackles high, ends up having hold of Tuilagi by the hair and the proceeds to drag him out of play. Like I said before I wouldn't care if I had hold of someone's hair in that situation, I would just want to get them into touch.

    But, at the end of the day, neither of us know what he was thinking. So we can blabber on until the cows come home about how we interpret the video. I just like to give people the benefit of the doubt, regardless of team/nationality/notoriety.
    (g. murphy included). It was dealt with by the ref at the time.

  • ronan
    10:53 PM 05/12/2011

    thats what happens when you have a girls hair cut!!! ha ha....

  • matthew
    10:00 PM 05/12/2011

    Perhaps Ashton got away scott free for the game in May, when he was yellow carded but shouldn't've been. Not saying he shouldn't have had a yellow here, but that decision last season might have played a part in Barnes's decision making, consciously or not.

  • matthew
    9:57 PM 05/12/2011

    Waiting for Murphy to be cited on the same grounds for cynical off-the-ball blocking late on ... and maybe for throwing punches too.

    Oh look, a flying pig!

  • mise
    9:46 PM 05/12/2011

    perhaps understandably, Tuilagi does immediately go for ashton. He tries to punch him, succeeds with the first one (punch into ribs, stomach area), mostly fails with the second, and after that its a melee. Tuiligi's intention to lay into Ashton is a serious part of it from the ref's perspective. he obviously just wanted to teach players a lesson, and didn't think yellow would do it. Maybe he was right in this regard? However Ashton did get away scott free, which is a pity - petty move on his part.

  • redyeti
    9:26 PM 05/12/2011

    Ashton's been cited for committing an act contrary to good sportsmanship or whatever that rule is they invoke whenever there isn't a specific offense to charge a player with. Tuilagi and Wood both cited for punching, but not Murphy...

  • johndoe
    8:40 PM 05/12/2011

    Good to know you understand a bit about gravity, I think you're missing the point though. I'm not trying to discuss gravity or anything. Still not sure how you think Ashton "slipped" up though. Doesn't really make sense. Anyway, it's pretty clear he grabs his hair with one hand and his shoulder with the other (unless you're an Ashton fan, of course).

    Not really... I don't know what was going through Geordan Murphy's head when he started throwing punches, but I know he did it on purpose. I see your logic, but use a bit of common sense as well.

    I can say he went for the hair for the reasons I wrote before. Did you not read them? It wasn't exactly a long paragraph man:

    "I get "purposefully going for the hair" because he had to move closer to Tuilagi to grab him by the hair. Ashton waited until he was close enough to pull him by his hair before he made his move. The higher up you are tackling, the closer you have to be to a player. He could have tackled the man sooner by going for his legs. He could easily have grabbed him by the arm, shoulders, jersey (I'm not sure why, but Tuilagi's jersey is baggier than most backs'). And then dragging him out by his hair was unnecessary and cowardly. Again, he could have gone for any other part of him as almost every other professional player does in these situations."

    Even if you forget about the initial pulling of his hair, I don't really see how dragging him out on his hands and knees by his hair could be accidental. You'd have to be a blind Northampton fan to think that.

  • johndoe
    8:25 PM 05/12/2011

    It's a shame we have people complaining when we get a nice punch up when there are plenty of place where they can discuss the match.

  • gnoballib
    7:06 PM 05/12/2011

    All the more reason to hate Ashton .

  • 6:45 PM 05/12/2011

    Most people usually watch Perpignan matches with one eye on average. If anyone used both eyes I think their brains would be overwhelmed by the red yellow hazard light omelette kit thing they have going on.

  • rich_w
    6:28 PM 05/12/2011

    What a well thought out post, really adding some depth and insight to the comment section. I would LOVE to hear you elaborate on why he should be banned from rugby... or maybe, I would rather you just went to youtube and spouted nonsense there.

  • 6:14 PM 05/12/2011

    Yeh exactly its such a shame we are talking about this rather than the match. The Ashton and Agulla tries were absolute peaches.

  • 5:28 PM 05/12/2011

    From my point of view Woods ran in throwing low digs (for those of you who didn't see him throw punches look again). Murphy ran in to pull him out and Woods then turned and swung first elbow, then fist at Murphy, Murphy threw two punches back (wrong by the rules but understandable as a player in that situation) and then continues to pull out players as he was doing beforehand (not to hide what he did).
    He then talks to the ref as he is the Captain..."as if he wasn't involved"...what was he supposed to do? Say "hey I know I'm the captain but I threw a few punches myself there, not sure I should talk to you"....That he was the worst offender is far from my opinion but hey, everyone has a right to their point of view.

  • buzzkillington
    5:23 PM 05/12/2011

    What's one eyed about supporting Perpignan over Northampton?

  • buzzkillington
    5:19 PM 05/12/2011

    You can't pull people by their hair in League, I assure you. Players have been pinged for grabbing the likes of Thaiday and Idris by the hair. There was also a fight the other year after Tadulala(can't spell it) was pulled by the hair, he now plays Rugby for Gloucester I think? It's definitely illegal though

  • rich_w
    4:06 PM 05/12/2011

    "Slip up? You don't slip up. That would be defying gravity. You would have to pull yourself up." - You can slip along any negative gradient, be that a GPE gradient (gravity) or simply the difference in girth between shoulders and head. Try it for yourself, put an elastic band around the shoulder of a wine bottle. Lo and behold!! the elastic band will 'defy gravity' and move upwards to the thin neck of the bottle.

    Also, you said "But I can't tell what was going through Ashton's head and neither can you" - Very true, agree with you 100%. So how can you say he purposefully went for the hair. You just contradicted yourself.

  • lnd
    3:32 PM 05/12/2011

    such a sham removing videos from youtube under copyright, can only be bad for the game.

  • rugby08
    2:26 PM 05/12/2011

    Exactly, if you're gonna grow hair like that expect it to be pulled now and again! lol Here come the trolls

  • johndoe
    2:15 PM 05/12/2011

    (@Casual Observer)

  • buzzkillington
    12:27 PM 05/12/2011

    Is using a machine gun actually an offence? Without a reference to a specific Rugby law is it therefore justified?

    What a silly argument.

  • buzzkillington
    12:26 PM 05/12/2011

    This was ridiculously dangerous. I'm not sure if it's been mentioned but the ball-boy gets caught up in the middle of it and bashed around. He was lucky not to catch a punch himself.

  • johndoe
    12:09 PM 05/12/2011

    By the way, why do you keep bringing up BOD? Yes he was feisty, but he taunt specific players after scoring, he didn't shout taunts at players on the ground after setting up tries, etc. So if you want to keep talking about BOD fair enough, I don't really understand why you want to though.

  • johndoe
    12:05 PM 05/12/2011

    I didn't say "his ability to defend, or whether he talks smack, or where he was taught to tackle and should have tackled". I don't even think I said it was a penalty. I think you might be mixing up what I wrote and what others wrote. And if it is against the law, then I would penalise BOD, however, Ashton certainly took it further than BOD did. I'd need to read up on the laws though.

    And I am not judging how culpable he is for this offense based on his reputation. That is irrelevant. I just think that it is pathetic to pull a man down by his hair and then to drag that man on his hands and knees by his hair.

  • johndoe
    11:56 AM 05/12/2011

    If you want to discuss the match, a better place would be a forum or a video f highlights of the match. It's fairly obvious what the debate is going to be about, looking at the video.

  • johndoe
    11:55 AM 05/12/2011

    1) As I said, they are not comparable incidents. And BOD's "tackle" was 7 years ago. It doesn't matter if the video was uploaded 3 years ago, not everyone will have watched the video.

    2) He failed in his first attempt at a tackle and so purposefully went for Tuilagi's hair the second time. When he got him to the floor, he dragged him out by his hair.

    3) They were closer than Agulla and the other Leicester player.

    4) Keep writing it because you seem to be missing the point. Different actions and different circumstances will of course be met with different attitudes, hence the negative comments towards Ashton and very few toward BOD.

  • pretzel
    8:26 AM 05/12/2011

    No one comments about BOD because it happened 7 years ago!!!! I.e it was probably posted on RD 7 years ago (if RD was even around then). Do you expect us to see an incident on the rugby pitch then search for hours on end for all similar activity, then make an overall comment on EVERY single video?

    Let's not forget how people's attitudes have changed, 7 years ago I'd expect this punch up to be viewed with a "handbags, get on with the game" stance, nowadays it is red card worthy to many people!

    I expect to see you dragging up videos of players spear tackling with no punishment the next time we see a red card spear and people saying "deserved the red".

    What do you propose we do? I have already said both hair pulling acts are lame, do you want me to make a YouTube comment to back it up?

  • 2:22 AM 05/12/2011

    Yeah that was my point john. A good match overshadowed by a teeny bit of overexcited hugging.

  • redyeti
    1:57 AM 05/12/2011

    1) Ashton should have been penalised for the hair pull.
    2) Tuilagi did nothing against the laws.
    3) Too many players sprinted over to single out Wood as retaliating
    4) Murphy was clearly throwing lots of very obvious punches at people's backs

    Conclusion: penalise Ashton, then reverse the penalty for Murphy's retaliation, red (or possibly yellow) Murphy, and maybe yellow Wood (although I can't see him actually throwing any shots). Then again I have the benefit of the replays...

  • johndoe
    11:45 PM 04/12/2011

    This video isn't about the match. It's about this particular incident hence the title and content of the video.

  • bnations
    11:39 PM 04/12/2011

    If you grow a handle on your head, you shouldn't be surprised if someone yanks it. Just sayin'.

  • bnations
    11:39 PM 04/12/2011

    If you grow a handle on your head, you shouldn't be surprised if someone yanks it. Just sayin'.

  • 10:55 PM 04/12/2011

    It's a shame we aren't talking about the match, was a good one. Could have gone either way. Did anyone see Jon Smit's yellow card this week? Possibly a Friday funny I think.

    On this video I don't think any card was needed at all, although after reading all these comments with so many people angry and emotional makes me quite like Ashton, he certainly isn't boring and he has one of the best strike rates in world rugby.

    Also Alesana deserved at least a yellow for his ridiculous hair. That man needs a haircut.

  • bunn
    10:13 PM 04/12/2011

    He pulled his hair, I don't see why everyone is so angry about it? The major part of the tackle is over the shoulder and he pulls for a short time before grabbing under the armpits. Nothing dangerous, so why are people so angry. Tuilagi did carry it on, but no way a red, Wood is a little unlucky and Murphy got lucky. Ashton and Manu got along at the world cup because they are professionals.

  • moddeur
    9:50 PM 04/12/2011

    I don't see Tuilagi landing or even attempting a single punch myself. Ashton's tackling by the hair is ugly play and deserves a yellow. The linesmen didn't see much, did he?
    Sidenote: how on earth did Ashton and Manu Tuilagi get along in the England squad during the RWC?

  • johndoe
    8:38 PM 04/12/2011

    Slip up? You don't slip up. That would be defying gravity. You would have to pull yourself up. But that didn't happen, he actually went straight for Tuilagi's hair. One hand is on Tuilagi's shoulder, the other is yanking his hair. I get "purposefully going for the hair" because he had to move closer to Tuilagi to grab him by the hair. Ashton waited until he was close enough to pull him by his hair before he made his move. The higher up you are tackling, the closer you have to be to a player. He could have tackled the man sooner by going for his legs. He could easily have grabbed him by the arm, shoulders, jersey (I'm not sure why, but Tuilagi's jersey is baggier than most backs'). And then dragging him out by his hair was unnecesary and cowardly. Again, he could have gone for any other part of him as almost every other professional player does in these situations.

    And no, you don't pull a man by his hair. Situations like this arise all the time and there is a reason why there aren't more clips like these: because it is a cowardly move. It's like kicking a guy in the balls in a professional fight, except a slightly lower level. You just don't do it. Anyway, Ashton didn't have to pull Tuilagi out by his hair so the issue of pulling a man's hair for the good of the team doesn't really apply here. Not to mention Lawes and Dickson were the two closest players to the incident, Ashton wasn't had help right beside him and .

  • pretzel
    7:28 PM 04/12/2011

    Yellows would have sufficed, and as said before would have meant Ashton would get a bruising later on in the game :)

  • 7:28 PM 04/12/2011

    All the more reason to hate Ashton. Very different from bod's who was really just reacting, whereas in the replay you can see Ashton targeting alesena's hair.

  • pretzel
    7:26 PM 04/12/2011

    Fact is I don't remember the bod incident being on RD maybe I wasn't on RD when it happened, but remember the amount of traffic that pours through here, there is bound to be more comments on RD now than 7 years ago... And how do you determine "tough motherfucker" is a pro BOD comment...?!?!?

    Heck I'm all for just getting on with the game and not getting caught up with "ban him for life" requests, but the argument you put forward which in someways takes a stance that we all want to kiss BOD for what he did, is just wrong.... Really both of the efforts are a bit Nancy... As are the red cards, I get worn out with reds shown for a fracus like that, did anyone see a decent connection?

  • johndoe
    7:15 PM 04/12/2011

    1) I didn't say they were week dependent. But you are making a point about people not criticising BOD. It happened 7 years ago. 1) Get over it 2) People might not remember a minor event which happened 7 years ago, which is a long time. I mean, BOD was 25 back then. 7 seasons is a fairly long time in rugby. 3) The incident isn't really comparable.

    2) Firstly, it would have been easier to go for Tuilagi's legs. Even if it wasn't easier, you don't purposely go for a player's hair. Secondly, after Ashton drags him down by his hair, he continues to drag him out of play by his hair. He could have stopped but he didn't.

    3) Personally, I think that's bullshit and you are just making excuses. But I can't tell what was going through Ashton's head and neither can you. All I know is that from the day kids start playing rugby they are taught to tackle the waist / leg area. They are never taught to go for a man's hair. Not only this, Ashton could have easily dragged him out by the jersey after he got him down. He had time (although minimal time would be required and if he had grabbed the ball, time would not even have been an issue), momentum was with him, the nearest players to him were Dickson and Lawes, not Agulla, and he even paused momentarily before he dragged him further. Either way, time or not, it was a pathetic move. Players are shoved / pulled into touch all the time without being dragged by the hair, even if pulling a player by the hair would be easier / quicker it isn't done because it is a bitch move.

    4) The initial pulling of the hair was slightly different between the two incidents and BOD did not continue and drag the player around by his hair. And BOD does not taunt opponents and BOD can defend.

  • rich_w
    6:54 PM 04/12/2011

    Not sure where you get purposefully going for the hair from. He tackles the shoulders and this slips up, has hold of the hair and then finally pulls him into touch with one hand in Tuilagis pit. I dont really see the issue.

    Quick question for those of you who play rugby. If your pulling someone into touch, as you want/need to for the good of your team. And all you end up grabbing is hair, do you stop tackling or just carry on pulling on whatever you do have hold of to ensure the ball goes dead. For me, No1 priority in that situation is get the man in touch, I don't care what I have hold of.

  • johndoe
    6:13 PM 04/12/2011

    Agree completely. If you've got long hair, it is going to get pulled at some point. However, I would take issue when another player purposely goes for your hair as Ashton does on this occasion. If a player is on their hands and knees as Tuilagi was, there is no need whatsoever to touch that players' hair.

  • johndoe
    6:10 PM 04/12/2011

    Who said it's hilarious? And how long ago was that? It's not as if he did it this weekend... besides, that was BOD flailing around trying to grab anything he can. Tuilagi was down on the ground on his hands and knees and Ashton had him at his mercy. He could have gone for the ball or easily grabbed anything but his hair, but he drags him out by his hair. BOD's was shitty tackling after being beaten by the runner. Ashton purposely went for Tuilagi's hair while he was in a vulnerable position and while there were other less pathetic options open to Ashton. Also, Ashton was shouting at Leicester players on the ground after he set up a try and he cost Northampton two tries. He is a terrible player, with a bad attitude who made a very bitchy move. Not at all the same as BOD.

  • juggernauter
    5:31 PM 04/12/2011

    *ridden

  • juggernauter
    5:29 PM 04/12/2011

    That f*cking Ashton... Alesana should have floored him for being a cunt and a sissy.

    Anyway, I just love watching the players being given the sending off and not complaining, not throwing their arms into the air, not abusing the referee... Rugby is a sport for real gentlemen, even in these money riffen pro days.

    Great to see

  • 5:26 PM 04/12/2011

    Dunno. Nothing really wrong with what happened - you go in with punches, expect a red card. Not that I mind seeing a small punch-up here and there, but a match-stopping brawl is unnecessary.

    Either way...if you've got long hair, expect it will get pulled at some point. But then if you pull someone's hair, expect to get a punch to the head and your team ought to give you some shit for a while about being a hair-pulling little girl.

    Yellows could have been used here, but red works just fine, and the laws say red is justified.

  • pretzel
    5:20 PM 04/12/2011

    Who said BOD doing it was hilarious? I clicked on your link, I read the YouTube comments, no one seemed to mention the hilarity of it....other thatn the Aussie commentators that is!

    I think it's a pretty poor way to tackle but I think those offended should take comfort in the fact that someone is going to tear Mr Ashton a new one sometime soon!

  • pretzel
    5:13 PM 04/12/2011

    Am I the only one that thinks "just get on with the game"?
    So Ashton pulled tuilagi's hair, give a penalty against him and that's it... A red card for punches?!? I get that it's in the law book, but again am I the only one that enjoyed the French club rugby punch ups? I'm not saying encourage it, maybe yellows are sufficient, but reds :/

    Really I'm surprised the IRB hasn't brought out an Amber card, which means 20 mins off the pitch... Really just get on with the game... Let tuilagi tackle Ashton into next week and we'd have enjoyed 2 RD videos from this game!!

  • patedelievre
    4:16 PM 04/12/2011

    +1

  • patedelievre
    4:14 PM 04/12/2011

    there's always been something between A. Tuilagi and Chris-the Prick-Ashton.
    such a shame to pull him by the hair... Ashton and Lawes are good, but they should be banned from the England Squad for their bad spirits and temper. England have enough good players to get shot of guys like them, together with Tuilagi.
    If England are to remain something of an example on the pitch, it comes with fair play, and they're losing it...both 3 are excellent players and would certainly not be replaced by equal players, but the negative impact they have on the team (such a pathetic WC campaign) proves that being shot of them would certainly be a great asset for the rest of the team. I tend to disagree with the idea that the team should put up with thugs just because they are good. might be okay in other sports, but rugby's way too much of a team-oriented game to let these guys in.

  • sithepie
    2:26 PM 04/12/2011

    Should have been one card there, to Chris Ashton. Disgusting to tackle by the hair, I hope he gets cited/ smashed into next week by Tuilagi in a different game.

  • yannoche
    2:25 PM 04/12/2011

    Arg, the only one to pity is the sound technician, being crushed by the pack of both teams! Poor guy, wrong place at the wrong time!

  • neilt
    2:19 PM 04/12/2011

    Still can't see the punches from Wood! (And by the way, I'm not doubting that he threw some!)

    Can't see how Richard Cockerill can defend Tuilagi here, even though he was provoked, he still threw punches! Should have been a further red for Murphy and possibly Lawes. Ashton should have got a yellow also.

    Also, spare a thought for the poor lad from ESPN with the microphone! More than likely caught a few wild arms! I reckon he needed to change his pants at half time!

  • 2:19 PM 04/12/2011

    I for one cannot wait for the next Alesana Tuilagi tackle on Ashton... CRUNCH

  • tanora
    2:16 PM 04/12/2011

    Ashton, you scummy little shit.

    I can't be bothered picking out who deserved cards and of what colour there, I just know that Ashton deserved to get flattened and I hope there's some way of banning him now. Yuck.

  • 2:16 PM 04/12/2011

    Can someone please drag that spammer ^^ out by the hair & give him a few punches instead?

  • johndoe
    2:10 PM 04/12/2011

    And I was very happy to see a bit of passion in a match. I know fighting shouldn't be encouraged, but it really adds an extra dimension to a game. Great stuff.

  • rugby08
    2:09 PM 04/12/2011

    Should have been a red for Geordan Murphy and a yellow for Chris Ashton.

  • johndoe
    2:08 PM 04/12/2011

    Some players were very lucky to be on the pitch. I saw 3 Leicester (Tuilagi 1, Agulla 1, Murphy 2) players throw punches and 2 Northampton (Lawes 1, Woods 2) players. Murphy was very lucky to stay on the field. Tuilagi didn't really connect and Agulla's looked more like a lazy slap. Woods and Murphy were the worst offenders though. I found it funny how Murphy started pulling people away from the fight to hide what he'd done and spoke to the referee after as if he wasn't involved.

    And absolutely petty and pathetic by Ashton. Pulling a man by his hair? Ashton needs to grow some balls and learn how to tackle. When he set up the try, he started jumping and screaming at the two Leicester defenders on the ground. Funny thing is that he let in two tries and cost Northampton the game for the second time in three weeks. The guy is pathetic and I have no idea why he thinks he can act that way, particularly after losing causing the loss of a game for a second time.